Exercise
Breathing Trainer Devices: Do They Work?
The handheld device you breathe hard through is one of the few breathing gadgets with genuine trial evidence behind it. 🫁
Your diaphragm and intercostal muscles are skeletal muscles, and like any skeletal muscle they respond to training against resistance. That is the entire premise of inspiratory muscle training, and it is better supported than most things sold for breathing.
How the devices work ⚙️
You breathe in through a mouthpiece against an adjustable resistance, usually a spring-loaded valve requiring a set pressure before it opens. That overloads the inspiratory muscles, which adapt by becoming stronger.
Two main types:
- Pressure threshold devices — the valve opens only above a set pressure, so the load is consistent regardless of flow rate. These are the ones used in most research.
- Flow resistive devices — an adjustable opening; the load depends on how fast you breathe, which makes it less consistent.
What the evidence shows 📊
Reviews of inspiratory muscle training report improvements in inspiratory muscle strength, breathlessness scores and exercise capacity across several populations, including COPD, heart failure and healthy athletes. Effects on breathlessness and inspiratory strength are reasonably consistent.
Some research has also looked at blood pressure effects from high-resistance protocols, though that is a separate and less established application. 📈
Who benefits most 👤
- People with COPD, particularly where inspiratory muscle weakness has been demonstrated
- Heart failure — inspiratory weakness is common and training has shown benefit
- Before and after surgery — pre-operative training has been studied for reducing post-operative pulmonary complications
- Athletes, where effects on performance are more modest and more debated
- Post-ICU recovery, where respiratory muscle weakness is common
A typical protocol 📋
Commonly studied: 30 breaths, twice daily, at a resistance around 50–60% of your maximum inspiratory pressure, for at least four to eight weeks.
Ideally the starting resistance is set from a measured maximum inspiratory pressure, which a respiratory physiotherapist can do. Without that, start at a setting where 30 breaths is hard but completable, and increase as it becomes easier.
Technique: sit upright, seal your lips around the mouthpiece, use a nose clip if supplied, breathe in forcefully and deeply, exhale normally. 🫁
How to tell a trainer from a toy 🔍
- Does it have a calibrated, adjustable resistance setting? A device with no adjustment cannot be progressed.
- Is it a pressure threshold device? These are what most research used.
- Does it train inspiration, expiration, or both? Different devices target different muscles; know which you want.
- Is it a lung exerciser or an incentive spirometer? Incentive spirometers — the ones with floating balls — are designed for post-operative lung expansion, not strength training. Different purpose entirely.
- Is it cleanable? It goes in your mouth twice a day.
Realistic expectations ⚖️
Inspiratory muscle training strengthens breathing muscles. It does not reverse lung disease, open narrowed airways or replace any medication. The improvement is in how breathless you feel at a given workload, which is genuinely worth having but is a specific and bounded claim.
It also works best as part of a programme including aerobic and resistance exercise rather than on its own — most research used it alongside broader training. 💡
Cautions ⚠️
Discuss with a clinician first if you have a history of spontaneous pneumothorax, recent chest or abdominal surgery, a perforated eardrum, uncontrolled hypertension, or unstable cardiac disease. Stop and seek advice for chest pain, dizziness or significant discomfort.
And if you are eligible for pulmonary rehabilitation, that comes first — a supervised programme has stronger evidence than any device used alone. Our pulmonary rehab guide covers how to get referred. ✅