Label literacy
What “Standardised Extract” Actually Guarantees
Two bottles of the same herb at the same milligram amount can differ several-fold in strength. Standardisation is the word that closes that gap. ๐งช
Plants are not uniform. The same species grown in different soil, harvested in a different month, extracted with a different solvent, produces materially different chemistry. Standardisation is the industry's attempt to deal with that, and it is one of the few label terms worth hunting for.
What it means
A standardised extract is processed so that a named marker compound is present at a guaranteed percentage. “Milk thistle standardised to 80% silymarin” means that in every gram of that extract, 800 mg is silymarin, batch after batch.
That lets you do real arithmetic. If research used 420 mg of silymarin daily, and a capsule contains 200 mg of 80% extract, you are getting 160 mg of silymarin and would need roughly three capsules to match. Without standardisation, that calculation is impossible. ๐
What it does not guarantee โ ๏ธ
- That the marker is the active compound. Sometimes it is just the easiest thing to measure. Plants contain hundreds of constituents and the marker may be a proxy rather than the agent.
- That higher percentage is better. A 95% extract has had more of the plant stripped away. If other constituents contribute, a 30% extract closer to the whole plant may perform better. Higher numbers look impressive and are not automatically superior.
- Quality of the raw material. Standardisation controls one compound, not heavy metals, pesticides or adulteration. That is what third-party testing is for.
- That the dose is adequate. A standardised extract at 5 mg is still 5 mg.
Standardisation versus ratio extracts ๐
You will also see ratios: 4:1, 10:1, 20:1. These say how much raw material went into the finished extract — 10:1 means ten parts plant became one part extract.
A ratio is not a standardisation and not a dose. It guarantees no compound at any level, and it can be manipulated: extract aggressively with a solvent that pulls mostly inert material and you can produce an impressive ratio with little of the constituent that matters.
When a label gives only a ratio and no milligram figure, as is common with mullein and several other respiratory herbs, you are being told almost nothing measurable.
Markers worth recognising ๐
- Horse chestnut — aescin, typically 16–20%
- Green tea — EGCG or total catechins, often 45–50%
- Ginger — gingerols, typically 5%
- Turmeric — curcuminoids, typically 95%
- Milk thistle — silymarin, typically 80%
- Bromelain — expressed in GDU activity units rather than a percentage
What to do with this ๐
When comparing two products, convert both to the actual amount of marker compound per day and compare that number, not the headline milligrams. It takes thirty seconds and frequently reverses which product looks better value.
And when a label gives no standardisation and no amount at all, recognise what that means: there is nothing to compare, and the decision rests entirely on trust and the refund window. โ